The thermian argument
Web6. david-saint-hubbins • 4 mo. ago. The commentary for The Limey (1999), directed by Steven Soderbergh and written by Lem Dobbs, has some really interesting and funny moments, particularly when Dobbs complains about the fact that Soderbergh got praised for stuff that was simply in the script. 5. garysdrunk • 4 mo. ago. WebTwitter: http://twitter.com/FoldableHumanAsk.fm: http://ask.fm/FoldableHumanWritten and Performed by Dan Olson
The thermian argument
Did you know?
WebThe diegetic argument aims to dismiss criticism at its cores, suggesting that there aren't any problems with the text provided controversial elements are internally consistent with the … WebIn the historiography of the French Revolution, the Thermidorian Reaction ( French: Réaction thermidorienne or Convention thermidorienne, "Thermidorian Convention") is the common term for the period between the ousting of Maximilien Robespierre on 9 Thermidor II, or 27 July 1794, and the inauguration of the French Directory on 2 November 1795.
WebNov 24, 2024 · You're invoking something like the Thermian argument here. While games ARE a set of rules, those rules are chosen by the developers and I'm not entirely convinced … WebJul 24, 2024 · A "Thermian Argument" is one that replies to criticism of a text with an in-universe justification for why the thing happens in the text, ignoring the actual argument in …
WebJul 22, 2024 · I meant point 1.) as the thermian argument--people making arguments based within the fiction of received pop cultural ideas--versus point 2.) as the ethics/politics- … WebIn the historiography of the French Revolution, the Thermidorian Reaction ( French: Réaction thermidorienne or Convention thermidorienne, "Thermidorian Convention") is the common …
On September 17, 2015, Dan Olsen, also known as Folding Ideas, uploaded a videowhere he discusses what he calls the ‘Thermian Argument’. The ‘Thermian Argument’ is composed to two parts and his conclusion: 1. Some elements in media are criticized, usually for racism or sexism. 2. Fans defend these … See more Dan describes the defense of controversial element via citing in-universe reasons as a ‘Thermian Argument’. He explains what the Thermians are in his video: … See more Recall that Dan considers the use of in-story reasons to defend controversial elements as an invalid argument because “stories are eternally mutable by creators”. … See more In fact, do they matter at all? Dan argues in the affirmative because of the possible real-world ramifications that may arise. According to him, the only things that exist … See more Dan names two hypothetical medieval games to show that the ‘Thermian Argument’ is contradictory. One game is historically accurate whereas the other has … See more
WebJul 22, 2024 · The Thermian Argument is misplaced at best for 4 core reasons and dozens of more minor ones. 1) Flesh as we know it doesn't have a myriad of different colors … tlf t shirtsWebNov 12, 2024 · Dan Olson argues in his video from 2015 that it’s not permissible to defend “problematic” content in a piece of fiction on the basis of verisimilitude – that is, on the … tlf talkmoreWebJul 23, 2024 · TL;DR - The 'Thermian Argument' is Absolute Sophistry . It sounds nice on the surface but the "Thermian Argument" doesn't hold up to scrutiny. It is absolutely fine to judge a piece of media using elements within that media. tlf susWebJul 22, 2024 · Huh, that's a Thermian argument right there. It's in-universe. But, at the same time, it also seems to hold explanatory power over why an author might have made the choices they did. The writer might be thinking, okay, "Goblins rape women to reproduce, so it makes sense that they would focus exclusively on female victims." tlf tatraWebAug 28, 2016 · The argument itself would still exist without Thermians being around to name the term after, it would just have a different name. Hell, in his video the guy straight up … tlf tarnówWebJul 22, 2024 · The Thermian Argument is a logical fallacy that occurs when a question or criticism concerning the political statements that can be gleaned from a game or other … tlf telefonoWebFeb 22, 2024 · Fake arguments for fake people By M.Schinke. Let’s get real about examining our fiction, OpinionNerds! For more articles, essays and reviews go to … tlf tank